MT4 vs MT5 – Features and Compatibility
Update: Starting from October 12th, 2009 the testing of the MT5 platform has begun.
It is expected to last for 5-6 month before the final product is released. Check out participating MT5 brokers.
Update: June 1st, 2010 – the Metatrader 5 platform has been released.
Update: January 18, 2011 – MetaQuotes Software Corp. has given an exclusive interview about MT5 to 100Forexbrokers.com.
MetaTrader 5 reflects the latest Forex industry development and demands as well as conform to the newest regulatory rules and standards, in particular about hedging and position management.
The Major Changes in MetaTrader 5
MetaTrader 5 Improvements
– High performance and outstanding working speed
– 3 chart-types, 21 timeframes and over 70 analytical tools
– 5 order types and 4 execution modes available for trading
– trading operations on different markets (Forex, options, futures and stocks, DOM – the depth of market feature)
– Advanced built-in reports on all trading activities
– Working with MQL5 will be easier: there will be more data types, structures, classes; it’ll be easier to transfer C++ source codes into MQL5, EA execution speed will increase
MT4 and MT5 Compatibility
Unfortunately, MetaTrader4 Language (MQL4) will not be compatible with MetaTrader 5 (MQL5). The decision was made in favour of new opportunities in programming language and execution speed, which to some regret of existing MT4 clients means, their custom indicators and EAs (.mq4 and .ex4 files) won’t work with the MT5 platform and need to be rewritten.
Here is the official announcement about MQ4 and MQ5 compatibility:
“From the beginning of MetaTrader 5 development, we thought that we will be able to save compatibility. And we said about it many times. But the numerous traders/developers requests made us change our mind. We`ve understood that just can’t make a new language compatible. At the same time, we have made MQL5 more powerful and in this way we gave you, traders and developers, more abilities – that was our main goal in developing MQL5 IDE. From one side, a new language with the new abilities, and from the other side – MQL4 and MQL5 compatibility. Unfortunately, these two aims can’t be reached at the same time.”
Common sense suggests that there should probably be some thoughts on adding MT4/MT5 compatibility tool, after all not all Forex traders are experienced C++ or MQL programmers, but the vast majority of them uses custom MT4 indicators nowadays. But this is just hopes…
MT5 Position/Order Management
To meet Forex industry standards, MT5 has changed the entire core of position handling. From now on MT5 traders will be able to keep only one position of any single trading instrument/currency pair.
Hedging at this point is eliminated and so is the separate management of two different in time orders on the same currency pair.
8:00am Long EURUSD 1 lot @ 1.2000,
and later added
12:00am Long EURUSD 2 lots @1.2500,
will be seen on Metatrader 5 account as one position “Long EURUSD 3 lots”.
This reflection of orders aligns with the new FIFO (first-in, first-out) rule implemented by NFA as an industry-standard in summer 2009.
Closing the above-mentioned orders will now look next way:
The first order to close is always the order that was initiated first, so it’ll always be the 8:00 am Long position to close in our example above.
Buying and Selling the same pair (hedging strategy) will result in zero positions being open.
Order handling: Metatrader 5 versus Metatrader 4
|Order||Buy 1.00 EURUSD||Buy 1.00 EURUSD||Sell 3.00 EURUSD|
|MT5||Buy 1.00 EURUSD||Buy 2.00 EURUSD||Sell 1.00 EURUSD|
|MT4||#1 Buy 1.00 EURUSD||#1 Buy 1.00 EURUSD#2 Buy 1.00 EURUSD||#1 Buy 1.00 EURUSD#2 Buy 1.00 EURUSD#3 Sell 3.00 EURUSD|
Will All Forex Brokers Transfer to Metatrader 5?
Definitely all NFA regulated Forex brokers in US will make the transfer, as they have to comply with new NFA rules.
Regarding other Forex brokers, we believe they will be free to choose: stay with MT4 or upgrade to MT5. Retail clients are expected to influence the choice: while there is a large demand for the MT4 platform base due to extensive use of MT4 custom indicators and reluctance to give up hedging and customary position management style, retail brokers should be able to provide the option.
If, however, there will be a tool to convert existing Expert advisors and indicators from MT4 to MT5, the process of introducing a new MT5 platform to retail clients will be smoother.
Platforms like this make trading the Forex market a lot considerably easier, they help implement risk management by giving traders the tools to do so (normally in the form of automatic orders) and also allow you to perform technical analysis by providing charting platforms. These platforms are only benefiting the financial trading space.
*Images and logos use don this page is a copyright of MetaQuotes Software Corp.
We don’t have any connections to MetaQuotes Software Corp., MetaTrader 4/5 and ATC